
Can an operation reduce urinary infections, HIV acquisition and cancer risk? Circumcision has been associated with these benefits. But this does not mean that every boy needs it.
Circumcision removes the foreskin, the skin covering the glans. Treating a disease and operating preventively on a healthy child are different decisions. The benefit depends on the starting risk, available alternatives and the consequences of acting or waiting.
What do professional organisations recommend?
There is no single worldwide recommendation. The Canadian Paediatric Society and the Royal Australasian College of Physicians do not endorse routine circumcision for every newborn boy. [1],[2]
In 2012, the American Academy of Pediatrics published a statement favouring the balance of benefits over risks, without recommending universal circumcision. That statement has expired. Its family information, updated in October 2025, still does not recommend routine circumcision for every newborn, while acknowledging potential benefits. [3],[4]
In Europe, EAU/ESPU guidelines set out medical indications and alternatives; the phimosis chapter does not address cultural or religious circumcision. It should not be read as a universal recommendation. [5]
Does it reduce urinary tract infections?
Yes, but it does not eliminate them, and the benefit matters more when a child is at higher risk. A healthy boy starts with a low risk; certain urinary tract abnormalities can change the balance. [2],[5]
The CIRCUP trial studied 91 babies with posterior urethral valves. Over two years, the estimated probability of a febrile urinary tract infection was 20% with preventive antibiotics and 3% when circumcision was added. This was a small study, with incomplete follow-up for some participants: these figures cannot be applied to every boy. [6]
For children with urinary abnormalities, the specialist considers this option within the overall treatment plan, alongside other measures. A positive urine culture alone is not a reason to decide on surgery.
Does it protect against HIV?
Trials in men in Africa found approximately a 60% lower relative risk of acquiring HIV through heterosexual sex with women. Protection is incomplete, and the finding cannot be extended to every transmission route. [7]
“Relative risk” matters: a 60% reduction would change a hypothetical risk of 1% to 0.4%, not zero. This example explains the calculation; it does not estimate an individual's risk.
WHO recommends voluntary medical male circumcision as part of combined prevention for adolescents aged 15 or over and adult men in settings with generalised HIV epidemics. This does not mean recommending surgery for every newborn in Europe, nor does it replace condoms, testing or PrEP when indicated. [7]
What about penile cancer?
This is an uncommon disease: approximately one case per 100,000 men each year in Europe. Early circumcision is associated with a lower risk, but the studies are mainly observational, and part of the association is related to pathological phimosis. [8]
Preventing this cancer alone does not justify routine neonatal circumcision. Avoiding tobacco, having persistent lesions assessed and following HPV vaccination recommendations are also relevant. [5],[8]
What risks and alternatives should families know about?
Bleeding, infection, healing problems or narrowing of the urinary opening can occur. Serious injuries are uncommon but possible. Risk varies with age, technique and practitioner experience; no single percentage applies to every situation. Appropriate anaesthesia, pain relief and follow-up are essential. [1],[2],[5]
A foreskin that cannot yet be pulled back may be normal in childhood. It should never be forced. When phimosis needs treatment, prescribed topical steroids can often be tried before considering surgery. In other circumstances, such as lichen sclerosus, circumcision may be indicated. [5]
Why is surgery on a healthy baby debated?
The operation is irreversible, and a baby cannot consent. The debate combines prevention, bodily autonomy and family beliefs. Children should be heard according to their maturity, and families should understand what postponing an intervention without an immediate indication would mean. [2]
Laws also differ. In Spain, Article 19 of Law 4/2023, and in Catalonia Article 45 of Law 13/2025, address genital modifications within healthcare for intersex people: they set restrictions below age 12, with medical exceptions, and consent conditions between 12 and 16. They should not automatically be described as a general ban on childhood circumcision. [9],[10]
Malta protects against deferrable interventions on sex characteristics, with regulated exceptions; Germany expressly allows parental consent for male circumcision under conditions. These laws have different scopes. “Non-urgent” also does not mean “unnecessary”. [11],[12]
What should we ask before deciding?
- What problem are we trying to treat or prevent?
- What benefit is expected for this child?
- Are there alternatives, and what happens if we wait?
- How will pain and possible complications be managed?
The decision needs balanced information and individual assessment. This article provides general information and does not replace a consultation with a specialist.
Related information
Sources
- Canadian Paediatric Society — Circumcision of baby boys (2021)
- RACP — Circumcision of Infant Males (December 2022)
- AAP — Circumcision Policy Statement (2012; expired)
- AAP — Should the Baby Be Circumcised? (10 October 2025)
- EAU/ESPU — Paediatric Urology: phimosis (2026)
- Harper et al. — CIRCUP randomised trial. Eur Urol 2022;81:64–72. DOI 10.1016/j.eururo.2021.08.024
- WHO — Voluntary medical male circumcision for HIV prevention
- EAU/ASCO — Penile cancer: epidemiology, aetiology and pathology
- Spain — Law 4/2023, Article 19
- Catalonia — Law 13/2025, Article 45; effective 20 January 2026
- Malta — Chapter 540, Article 14 (consolidation includes 2024 amendments)
- Germany — BGB, section 1631d
